Portfolio companies owned by buyout firms of all sizes are facing the possibility of restructuring or bankruptcy.
February 2, 2009
Just like their counterparts in the investment banking universe, private equity firms in both the large and middle markets are also feeling heat from the economic downturn. Portfolio companies owned by buyout firms of all sizes are facing the possibility of restructuring or bankruptcy.
"It's no surprise that in times like these private equity firms that were bullish in the past might run into some issues with portfolio companies," says John Jonge Poerink, managing partner of middle-market private equity firm LJH Linley Capital.
"Middle-market portfolio companies are not totally dissimilar to larger private equity deals that have been done," says Charles Weissman, co-chair of the business restructuring and reorganization group at Dechert. "Two years ago, many of these companies took on a lot of debt and are now overleveraged, and that's because lending institutions were going easier on credit. Even in the middle market, there were covenant-light loans, and many companies that went the private equity route two or three years ago will probably have covenant problems this year."
Last week, Jon Moulton, managing partner of London-based mid-market private equity advisory firm Alchemy Partners, made headlines by telling attendees at the London Stock Exchange Alternative Investments Conference that he would not be surprised if 30% of middle-market private equity portfolio companies failed during the recession. Moulton told IDD, a sister publication to MAR, his analysis only applies to European companies.
However, in the US and other markets, it is difficult to determine exactly how many private equity portfolio companies-both large- and middle-market-are distressed. "Private equity firms are privately-held investment firms with limited partners that invest predominantly in private companies, so other than reporting to their limited partners, this type of information is typically kept confidential among the general partners and investors," says Poerink. "But, portfolio companies are certainly affected by this tough, unprecedented macroeconomic climate."
Of course, not all troubled portfolio companies necessarily have to file for bankruptcy protection. "The question is what 'failure' means," says Mark Bane, co-head of the bankruptcy and business restructuring group at Ropes & Gray. "People are focusing on whether there is going to be an onslaught of bankruptcies, or whether companies that need tinkering will be able to implement recapitalizations or capital structure adjustments without having to resort to Chapter 11. You see liquidations in the retail space, but no heightened liquidations or threats in any other space."
Many companies are benefiting from payment-in-kind toggle or covenant-light loans which, in earlier eras, would have triggered bankruptcies or more expedited restructurings.
"It's a race against time as to which will happen first-the expiration of covenant-light loans or the end of the recession," says Bane. "There are a lot of companies in that situation now. They're hoping the market turns around quick enough that they can avoid hitting the ground."
Bane says his practice is working with many small US companies from various sectors, including automotive supply, retail, computers and consulting. If the recession lasts for two or three years, there will inevitably be more companies pursuing some degree of restructuring, but many troubled entities will avoid having to do so if the economy turns around this year.
"Besides the issue of market performance, a significant challenge is presented by deals in which debt is coming due in the short term in a credit market where you can't find anyone to refinance them," says Bane. "If they have bond debts in place for three to four years they could be optimistic that the market could open up before then, but if they're coming due in 2009, they're concerned."
Debt absolutely trumps individual performance. "A maturity is a maturity, even if you have a portfolio company that's performing well," says Poerink.