Ken MacFadyen

Mr. MacFadyen is the editor of Mergers & Acquisitions Journal. Prior to joining the magazine, Mr. MacFadyen served as managing editor of Investment Dealers Digest and Buyouts Magazine.

He received his bachelor of arts in English from the University of New Hampshire (Phi Beta Kappa).

Ken can be reached at ken.macfadyen@sourcemedia.com.

The PE Fantasy Draft

I used to be pretty good at fantasy football. These days, the job tends to get in the way. For the second time in a row, I’m a likely no show for the draft, scheduled for this Wednesday. My team will be picked as I toggle between copy editing and the Yahoo draft screen, and I’ll invariably have at least one atrocious selection. Last year, they were Matt Cassel and Eddie Royal.

Recognizing that I’d probably be better off picking a fantasy private equity team, I’m introducing my inaugural PE fantasy draft board.

My draft strategy always revolves around getting a stud running back who’ll take most of the carries. I mistakenly deviated from this strategy once, and ended up with Dante Culpepper in the first round, who was dropped after throwing eight interceptions with two fumbles in the first two games. After the first round, I’ll shift into an opportunistic approach, targeting the best talent available. And then I’ll close the draft with either the defense or kicker. For sake of consistency, I’ll use this same strategy in assembling my PE team.

I’m assuming for this PE draft that I have a mid-round pick. Schwarzman, Black and Kravis probably got snapped up early on, so the focus for me is on consistency. My gut tells me to go with Warren Hellman, but Wilbur Ross is still available and he’d be a good play in this market. The safe pick is Hellman, though, who has proven to be a workhorse type of back that regularly puts up sold numbers. It’s a pick I’m happy with.

In the second round, I’m thinking receiver. This is a position that I always put off until the later rounds and it burns me every year. Receivers tend to be tough positions to draft. They’re divas, so it’s easy to waste a pick on someone that either works their way into the doghouse or goes through the motions because they’re angry their coach shut down their Twitter page. Ron Burkle is a fit, but he moonlights more as an activist investor these days than as a true PE sponsor. In the same way I’m turned off by Ochocinco’s turn on Dancing with Stars, I’m taking a pass on Burkle. For my money, Justin Wender is a good pick in this spot. He’s the middle market’s Anquan Boldin. I’m not sure where he’ll end up ultimately, but I think he’s less risky than Burkle, with a higher ceiling.

In the third round, I’m going to pass again on quarterback. Value is available in the later rounds for that position; for the tight ends, the drop off between the good and mediocre occurs right around here. You need a player who has the fundamentals down so they’re not a liability on the line. Of course, you need a scorer too, who has the skills to put up the points. It’s not the flashiest position, but it can be a difference maker. Good tight ends also make plays happen. They’re usually a checkdown option for the quarterback. Leonard Green’s John Danhakl is my pick here. Typically fantasy football isn’t for stat geeks, but for the tight end position in particular you want to know if they’re getting downfield opportunities or putting up yards after catch. Leonard Green has been creative in putting deals together, whether it’s through a PIPE, a taking private or traditional LBO. The firm has also quietly overperformed, which makes this a good value pick.

For the quarterback, DNA is important. It’s why college football coaches tend to gravitate to recruits whose fathers coached them in high school. The Gores brothers are probably private equity’s version of the Mannings -- the question I’m faced with, though, is which one is Peyton and which one is Eli. For this I’d normally refer to the statistics, but in this case the numbers are pretty comparable. I’m going with another gut decision to back Tom Gores.

The kicker, while a later round selection, can also be a difference maker. Like the quarterback, DNA can be important here. The Gramatica brothers are a case in point. I also make this selection based on the franchise. You can have the best kicker in the world, and if their offense doesn’t get them into field goal position, they’re worthless. In this case it’s a toss-up between Advent’s Steve Tadler and his brother TA Associate’s Richard Tadler. But I’m also a traditionalist when it comes to kickers -- a foreign accent gives me more confidence that they won’t be psyched out by a 50 yarder with the game on the line. For that reason, the pick is Advent’s Tadler. He doesn’t have a foreign accent, but he spent a number of years in the UK overseeing the firm’s European operations. Also, Advent is a franchise that’s going to put up numbers, which makes Tadler a safe pick.

The defense also isn’t a throw-away pick even though I saved it for the later rounds. Defense in private equity is operational capabilities. I also want a unit that can score points. KPS Capital’s Michael Psaros is an easy pick for this slot. They’ve had four dividend recaps alone this year, which is the equivalent of a pick-six.

Of course, a fantasy draft isn’t complete without a sleeper pick. For that one, I’m taking a flyer on Eric Zinterhofer, the Apollo Management vet, who launched Searchlight Capital earlier this year.

Recent Posts

DEAL DISCOURSE

Links from the week.

MidMarketREWIND

M&A highlights from the past seven days.

DEAL DISCOURSE

Links from the week.

MidMarketREWIND

M&A highlights from the past seven days.

Index of Posts

16 Comments

Spring coming up, Louis Vuitton Outlet Store the Louis Vuitton Outlet Online all-match classic medium bag will be for you but a simple, open design, reflects the bag atmospheric!

Posted by: leo c | February 23, 2012 9:13 PM


Discount UGG Boots Rush into the ward, found that jasper is awake, policewomen are recorded statement.

cheapest uggs ever Set aside time to see each work by fifty yuan per capita traveling expenses. tmd08cd

ugg kenly black Dedication means she will not do club service, eight hours will not live here worried about their children, the motivation to work.

hot pink ugg boots This small hotel is a lot of people's life, but always want to jump out of stones.

www.uggsaustralia.me.uk Last night his wife called to say, tomorrow morning see the child.

Posted by: cheapuggs b | February 8, 2012 3:08 AM


It's not the flashiest position, but it can be a difference maker. Good tight ends also make plays happen. essay writing | Coursework Writing | Assignment writing | Dissertation Writing | Thesis Writing

Posted by: padma l | February 1, 2012 11:30 AM


It is good to see some detailed information on this topic which is very rarely discussed on the internet donna cerca uomo milano thanks very much chiamami.

Posted by: Jack L | February 1, 2012 9:04 AM


very informative blog you have, thanks for sharing seo companies australia, web design service, seo companies in australia

Posted by: paul y | January 31, 2012 4:15 AM


This type of track record can make it tough for bankers fighting the perception that 50% of all deals fail. I would also think that it would scare some from selling out, yet new deals continue to crop up. I was even talking to a banker at an independent firm earlier this year who cited that a sale is ultimately the outcome most boutiques are hoping for. natural pink lips = how to get pink lips = lip care = winter lip care = home made lip gloss = home made lip balm =

Posted by: ozil j | January 30, 2012 1:41 AM


It is important to choose right one since the first time. Thank you for the tips. Proper care will save money in long term. social bookmarking submission | manual social bookmarking

Posted by: satish b | January 24, 2012 6:50 AM


This is very casino blackjacket iquette much inspired by the great technology free casino blackjack is visible in this blog that to bonus for casino games great services in this blog. I am very instant poker bonus much happy for the great technology is flash poker games visible in this blog. Amazing services are top casino gambling display in this blog that to sharing the play texas pokeronline nice services in this blog. This is really admired casino gambling games for the great technology is visible in casino roulette online this blog. Thanks a lot for using the casino freebonus no deposit nice technology in this blog.

Posted by: josephsholland j | January 24, 2012 3:40 AM


coach outlet online coach outlet louis vuitton uk louis vuitton coach outlet online coach factory outlet coach outlet coach outlet store online louis vuitton sale louis vuitton outlet coach factory outlet coach factory online coach factory outlet coach factory outlet online louis vuitton uk louis vuitton coach outlet online coach outlet coach outlet store coach outlet store online coach bags coach outlet store coach outlet coach outlet store online hermes birkin hermes bags gucci uk gucci uk sale louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton bags

Posted by: CHEN M | January 14, 2012 2:59 AM


The staffs are very good for providing the nice info in this technology. I am very happy for providing the nice info in this website. Thanks a lot for providing the great info in this website.photography tips, top web hosting, check website traffic, online sports games, Cheap used cars, how to get white teeth, search Engine optimization, Cheapest Car Insurance, travel advisory, olympic hockey.

Posted by: seo i | December 1, 2011 2:57 AM


I am very glad to see the online gambling amazing articles is visible poker slotsinformation in this blog free casino stoday that to using the nice technology casino tipsonnet in this blog. This is playcard games really satisfied by the nice services playcard games in this blog. This is poker playingblog very much impressed with the great services in poker playingblog this blog that poker playingblog to sharing the nice services in this blog. Thanks a lot for the great info is visible in this blog that to using the nice info in casino reviews this website

Posted by: watson s | November 22, 2011 4:54 AM


The

Coach Outlet Store

officials warned protesters which they do not possess the best

Coach Factory Outlet Online

This philosophy has made

Discount Coach Purses

are a convenience for the

Coach Outlet Store Online

. The

Coach Factory Outlet

of the

Coach Outlet Online Store

is the convenient shopping experience free each valued

Coach Factory Outlet

. broadest and most popular categories

Cheap Coach Purses

My family has only a small white

Cheap Outlet USA

If you are interested in , The holder of over 500

Prada Outlet

existing. The goal of the

Nike Air Yeezy

is to meet the

Gucci Handbags

wishes and requirements of different types of

Dunk Shoes

. The shopping

Coach Handbags Outlet

, the

Puma Outlet

can be divided into two focal

Supra Shoes

. In the shopping preferences, customers have the decision of purchasing a suitable

Coach Bags Outlet

which are this approach

Air Max

. Potential customers department so they can function

Coach Factory Outlet Online

Search Results

Posted by: DFGH D | November 20, 2011 9:35 PM


I wanted to thank you for this great read!! property in dubai appartement dubai apartment for rent in dubai event companies Dubai

Posted by: mike c | November 20, 2011 5:53 AM


I really like how you are explaining. This is definitely so much like a nfl draft. This is how you have to explain this. I am glad to see the great work on this. Keep up the good work. Sex Toys Canada

Posted by: john j | November 19, 2011 2:08 PM


The dragon tattoo should not be too complex since it costs a lot to maintain the tattoo and to remove it tattoo supplies. The dragon also loose it's spirit when the decoration is a bit too much.

Posted by: Jack C | November 18, 2011 2:28 AM


cowboys Jersey,Marion Barber Jersey,Felix Jones Jersey,Miles Austin Blue Jersey Yes, ladies and Terrell Owens Blue Jersey gentlemen, these Rams Deion Sanders Blue Jersey deserve a win. Dez Bryant Blue Jersey And this week they got Troy Aikman Blue Jersey a big shot in the arm Tony Romo Blue Jersey when they picked up Marion Barber Blue Jersey Brandon Lloyd, Tashard Choice Blue Jersey via trade, from the Felix Jones Blue Jersey Denver Broncos. Lloyd knows this offense.

Posted by: kaijili e | November 14, 2011 3:34 AM

Add Your Comments...

Already Registered?

If you have already registered to Money Management Executive, please use the form below to login. When completed you will immeditely be directed to post a comment.

Forgot your password?

Not Registered?

You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.